Ben Peek (benpeek) wrote,
Ben Peek


went and saw Solaris tonight. despite my previous claim to stay away from steven sodenberg films, i failed. i saw an interview with him and george clooney, and about how they made this film hey wanted too which made no money and got some minor critical acclaim. that's what did it. i was also interested in seeing what a science fiction film from hollywood that wasn't about being in space, or about it being 'science fiction' would be like.

in short, Solaris fails.

it happens right at the end, when the station is going down. the film is basically an exploration of love that tries to become a love story, and force a happy ending down upon the viewer. given the fact that george clooney's wife is dead, and he's being sucked into a planet, the idea is misplaced. but it is with the end of the film that most of it falls apart. there is, primarily, not enough story meat to hang onto the narrative, not enough of anything left at the end of the film to provide a strong end, and this is why everything fails. in addition to this, small twists are simple to pick, and so is clooney's final decision.

however, the film isn't bad for the most part. it succeeds totally in bringing a science fiction film that is exploring love, and the ethics and morals behind it, without resulting in pointless gadgets. space and the planet solaris form a sort of visual metaphor for the film that, while i think doesn't completely work, give it a sense of place.

but still, it fails in the end. which is a shame, i think.

  • John Clute on Steampunk: Revolution, edited by Ann Vandermeer.

    John Clute wrote about Steampunk III: Revolutions on Strange Horizons and my story, 'Possession', gets a nice mention: Some of the stories…

  • Sirius Reviews

    Here's a pair of responses from Locus and Tangent Online. The first is Lois Tilton: Contamination. A human colony on a planet gifted to them by…

  • Above/Below in Locus

    A review of Above/Below appeared in Locus by Rich Horton: Also worth a look is the linked set of novellas, ‘‘Above’’ by Stephanie Campisi and…

  • Post a new comment


    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded