?

Log in

The Past | The Previous

An Inconvenient Truth

In An Inconvenient Truth, Australia warrants one significant mention: it is one of the two first world countries who have refused to sign the Kyoto Agreement.

(The first, of course, is the United States. According to the film, a lot of the States, however, have pledged to sign up to it, a thing that I am not aware of any of the States doing here.)

As a whole, however, the documentary functions as a tour guide through climate change, narrated by the man who could have once been President, Al Gore. Gore reveals himself to be a warm voice, fatherly with its Southern twangs to hide his intelligence, and he is careful not to point the finger at various political factions (one suspects that he is aware of the hypocrisy if he did). Still, the attraction of the film is not Gore, since, in truth, any individual with a hint of performance could have done his job. Rather, it is the astonishing images of decay and loss that draw you in: the snows from Kilimanjaro disappearing, the packed ice in Greenland dissolving, scenes from New Orleans during Katrina, smoke ridden oil refineries, and parts of Africa so dry the ground is like a warped jigsaw puzzle. It's true that it is a very American centred view, and that none of these places are given an actual voice, but if the statistics in the film are right about America's status as the leader of greenhouse gases, then perhaps it should be.

Is it a film worth seeing, despite that?

Yes.

I don't know much about science, and indeed, I don't know much about the climate change debate. I read an article that the film is quite accurate, if occasionally simplistic (the rise in birth rates in poor nations is simply glossed over, for example), and I thought the film could have made more out of the political decisions to throw doubt and ridicule scientists findings--for example, they could have used one of these scientists in place of Gore's own life, which doesn't really have a lot to do with the film at all. But the film does succeed in giving someone like me--no nothing, not going to dedicate his life to the cause me--a reminder about cutting down on the type of wastage that already takes place. Every now and then, I figure it's good for me to have that reminder.

And what I figure is good for me, I figure is good for you.

Comments

( 3 Soaking Up Bandwidth — Soak Up Bandwidth )
girliejones
Oct. 9th, 2006 01:41 am (UTC)
ooh ooh ooh!! Yes the states here are doing a very similar thing, mine in particular is working towards reaching similar goals to those we would have signed under Kyoto and the states are working on carbon trading schemes etc.
benpeek
Oct. 9th, 2006 03:17 am (UTC)
hey,t hat's good to hear bout the states.
girliejones
Oct. 9th, 2006 03:18 am (UTC)
yeah sounds like we're all bypassing the Feds - all labour govts in any case.
( 3 Soaking Up Bandwidth — Soak Up Bandwidth )