?

Log in

No account? Create an account

The Past | The Previous

Spaghetti Western, Scott Morse.

I dig Scott Morse's graphic novels. Really dig 'em. There's a real cinematic quality to his panel layouts, and a grasp of dialogue that is just a joy, even when some of the plots might be a bit lacking.

Spaghetti Western, Morse's latest outing, keeps up a theme of my recent posts, which is talking about things related vaguely to Sergio Leone. This will probably stop soon enough, so for those reading and thinking, with irritated little sighs in the back of their throat that go "He's talking about Leone again," you'll be spared soon enough. At any rate, Morse is a big Leone fan too, because he has taken the director's signature style of close up facial shots and wide sceneries and made an one hundred and thirty odd page graphic novel that follows two men as they walk into a modern bank and hold it up, western style.

The joy of Spaghetti Western comes partly from the design of the book. Morse has designed it so that it mirrors the cinemascope lens used in movie theatres (and called widescreen on tv), so that, while on the shelf it resembles a paperback sized graphic novel, it is instead meant to be turned onto its side to be read. Inside, you'll find a similar page layout that Morse used with South Paw, in that each page is a separate panel, rather than being divided into a series of panels on one page. It worked well in South Paw, and it works well in Spaghetti Western, especially in the scenes where the Man With No Name (looking just like Eastwood, in fact) squares off for the duel at the end of the book.

The weakness of the book is the plot, which is a touch on the simple side. In fact, it's simple to the point where talking about it outside the initial premise of men dressed as cowboys holding up a bank gives away the twists and turns that it takes. They're not bad twists, but the cast is small: no more than six characters, and this includes tellers and such. So it's better to simply not go into any detail about the plot, I think, except to say that there's nothing wrong with it outside a desire to have something a bit meatier. The final scenes, the showdown, as all westerns must have them, is pretty damn cool, however. The final pages of Spaghetti Western are the strongest in the book, filled with Leone's sensibility as channeled through Morse, and ending perfectly.

One of the risks that Morse ran with Spaghetti Western was that he could have been accused of just simply ripping off Leone. It could have happened. Had he not switched it to a modern setting, and had he not provided, beneath the spaghetti western genre tendency for unrealistic characterisation, a pair of characters that were grounded in a realist sensibility, he would probably had succeeded in only ripping off Leone. Nor is the a pastiche, or a gentle nudge and joke towards the Leone films (or the whole spaghetti western genre), but rather a respectful, even loving use of the style that infuses each page, perfectly creating the tone and sensibility that carries the narrative through to those final, dare I suggest, perfect pages.

The one thing that struck me as odd, however, is Morse's opening introduction, where he talks about westerns being part of the comedy genre. Now, while I don't think they're part of the genre, I don't disagree with the fact that they have humour either, as many are quite funny, intentionally or not, and I think the Leone films in particular have a great sense of humour. But, I wonder if Morse set out to write something funny, or if that introduction was a ruse, an attempt to set the reader up for a story that was, really, not comedic at all. Sure, it had a few funny moments... but comedic?

No.

Totally worth reading, however.

Comments

( 5 Soaking Up Bandwidth — Soak Up Bandwidth )
shadowsandice
Sep. 3rd, 2004 07:44 am (UTC)
*adds to wishlist*
studebakerhawk
Sep. 3rd, 2004 06:57 pm (UTC)
Couldn't agree more; picked up Spaghetti Western last week and loved it. This whole graphic novel thing is something of a comeback tour for me. I neglected them for years, and now i've been inhaling stuff like Stray Bullets and Sandman. Have yet to stray down the Alan Moore path, as i have no idea where to begin.
benpeek
Sep. 3rd, 2004 09:54 pm (UTC)
yeah, i didn't get into them until about six or seven years ago. part of it was, i think, because there was no exposure of them over here, and the net had yet provided a way to find things that weren't superhero stuff. don't get me wrong, some superhero stuff is great, and i still buy single issue comics, mainly because they're six to eight months ahead of graphic novels, and you can try before you buy in some cases. but the graphic novel growth has been nothing short of superb and useful in allowing me to find things like STRAY BULLETS and morse's work. (i love STRAY BULLETS, i must add. just love.)

as for moore, i guess the places to start at the places that changed the comic scene: WATCHMEN and FROM HELL. both are fantastic and will appeal in different ways. moore has done a lot of stuff, and all of it is entertaining, like LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARY GENTLEMEN and TOP TEN, but those two are the ones that hit on every level, that were serious and thoughful and... well, just seminal, i guess. the other stuff is great. i have a particular fondness for LEAGUE OF EXTRAORDINARY GENTLEMEN and the rest of the ABC line (and the movie of league was awful and nothing like the graphic novel).
jack_ryder
Sep. 4th, 2004 07:30 pm (UTC)
I've heard a lot about Scott Morse, so I should start picking some up. I've diminished my comix intake incredibly so I've missed a lot of the good indy stuff around nowadays.

Do you know if Kinokiniya stocks "Spaghetti Western"?
benpeek
Sep. 4th, 2004 11:02 pm (UTC)
yeah. i bought my copy from there. eighteen bucks.
( 5 Soaking Up Bandwidth — Soak Up Bandwidth )